THUMPeta...wuh-THUMPeta...wuh-THUMPeta.
Our youngest two thundered up the basement steps, responding to the call that dessert -- pink-frosted Valentine’s Day sugar cookies -- was ready on the table.
“Did you guys pick up the basement and shut off the lights?”
I ask the same question at the end of every day. Mostly because their response isn’t always in the affirmative. And also because when the response is in the affirmative, oftentimes the evidence in the basement indicates otherwise.
Eyes locked on the plated sugar discs resting too few arm lengths away, Anna and Josie both nodded. Anna even tossed in an enthusiastic, “Yep!”
Her conviction made a believer out of me. In fact, I didn’t even bother with my “so-you’re-telling-me” test, as in, “So, you’re telling me that if I went down to the basement playroom right now, I’d find everything back in its place?”
I’ve been invoking the test a lot lately. White lies have become a recent problem for the youngest two. It has become a big enough problem where Tony and I threatened that any lie of any shade would result in a dessert- and candy-free existence for the rest of the year. We figured it an effective deterrent.
I pointed to the cookies and they filed into the bench side of the kitchen table. “Mmmmmm! These cookies are AWWWWWWESOME!,” Anna sang. Josie’s mouth was too full to agree with words. Instead, she bobbed her head vigorously toward Anna, eyes wide.
I turned to the stove to heat up the water in the kettle. By the time I’d turned back around, both girls were scooting out of the bench, nothing by a few crumbs on their napkins. Olivia, just home from swim practice, was late to her cookie but she finished it just as quickly and we hustled the girls to bed.
Lights out, I headed to the basement to put in a load of laundry. As I rounded the second floor landing, I felt glad that we put everyone to bed happy. Not that the girls go to bed unhappy, but I’ll admit that by the time the end of the day rolls around, my parenting could channel a little more Carol Brady and a little less Betty Draper.
The light to the basement steps was still on and I sighed: Let it go, Jen. You only asked them to turn off the lights in the playroom. So, technically, no lie. I kept on down the stairs and turned to the laundry without even looking at the playroom. One load into the washer and another out of the dryer, I headed back toward the stairs with a hamper on my hip when I noticed the pile of blankets inside the playroom door. On the floor.
Not a chance anyone attempted to fold the blankets. And an even lesser chance that anyone had so much as lifted a finger to put away any one of the 6,725 toys that littered the playroom floor.
Betty was gone. Carol had already fled the country. Joan Crawford texted and was a mere 30 seconds away.
Muuuuutherrrr EFFFFFF-errrrr!!!!!
I was livid.
I could believe that the basement was a mess. What I couldn’t believe was that Anna and Josie lied about it -- again -- and then happily polished off a dessert. How lucky for them that I’d seen Mommie Dearest one too many times as a child. I decided to sleep on my anger, rather than yank them from their beds and douse them in talcum powder, among other things.
Breakfast Friday morning seemed to be as good a time as any for the ambush. “Hey guys,” I started, eyes locked on Anna and Josie. They were seated across the table in the same place where they’d eaten their last dessert for 2013 just hours before. “So, I went down to do laundry last night in the basement...”
Their response was almost Pavlovian. Heads hung low, eyes looked up. They knew.
“What do you think I saw?” Oh, the faces of shame. Rhetorical questions are condescending, I realize, but so is being lied to.
Josie was first, “We didn’t clean the basement...”
“Do you remember what I asked you last night before you had dessert?”
Anna was next, “You asked us if we’d cleaned up the basement.”
“And did you?”
This time, in unison: “No.”
“And you both understand the punishment for lying, yes?”
They both nodded. “No more desserts or candy,” Anna muttered.
They’d come full circle. First, partners in crime, then partners in truth. And, sadly for them, now united in punishment.
What followed was me explaining that lying is hurtful and, more importantly, it makes Tony and I less likely to believe them when they are telling the truth. I told them I was disappointed -- something I’ve found motivates my kids more than my anger.
Then, I had to remove the sugar cookie half from Anna’s lunch -- a special treat I’d packed, knowing she thought the cookies were songworthy. The whole scene was borderline theatrical, but necessary nonetheless.
It was time to walk to school and Anna, who was remarkably silent -- except for Olivia who said, “Geez, telling me that I couldn’t have dessert for the rest of the year if I lied would be enough for me to tell the truth!” (I reminded her that she’d had her own issue with lying when she was six) -- put on her snowpants and jackets. Josie stayed behind with Tony.
Halfway to school, I broke the silence. I wasn’t about to capitulate, but I know that kids are kids. And I also know that for the most part, the girls are well-behaved. So I told Anna that I loved her, but I wasn’t all that fond of the lying. I also told her that if we see that she’s being more responsible, cleaning up without a daily reminder and, most importantly, starts being truthful all the time, that we’d let up a bit eventually.
“We need to see a change, though,” I said. My look was tender, but my voice was stern. A little bit of Carol. And a little bit of Joan.
For three days now, Anna and Josie haven’t fallen off the truth wagon. But until we see some changes in behavior, I won’t stop baking. Not because I’m mean. But because it’s something I like to do.
In the meantime, they’ll do without desserts and candy and we’ll hope for consistent truth. And while it might not be as true for them as it is for us, nipping a lying habit in the bud tastes a lot sweeter than a sugar cookie ever could.